A federal judge just forced Zohran Mamdani to hand ICE the names of homeless men in a Bronx shelter.
At the same time, Mamdani's staff was quietly begging the same agency to let other people go.
That backchannel into the West Wing just ran into Stephen Miller.
Mamdani's Staff Quietly Asked Trump to Free Two Dozen Detained New Yorkers
Politico reported on November 9, 2026, that Mamdani's team had been quietly lobbying the White House to release immigrants held by ICE.
The requests went through former Chief of Staff Susie Wiles, according to two people with knowledge of the outreach.
In February, federal agents detained Columbia University student Elmina Aghayeva, and Trump agreed to free her the same day after a White House sit-down.
Mamdani also secured a short-term visa for a grieving mother from Ghana whose son was shot and killed in the Bronx.
Mamdani gave the administration roughly two dozen more names during a September meeting with Trump at Gracie Mansion.
Politico could not confirm that the White House released anyone else on the list.
Mamdani told Fox News, "Over the course of these conversations, we have been able to free a New Yorker from ICE detention."
Mamdani ally Murad Awawdeh called Miller "a cruel man who has spent his career targeting immigrants."
Mamdani's public brand is built entirely on fighting ICE in court and in the press.
Privately, his staff was asking the same agency for favors one name at a time.
Mamdani has pledged his administration will never help ICE with civil immigration enforcement and will not be part of any deportation effort.
He tells immigrant New Yorkers at every opportunity that they do not have to open the door for ICE agents.
That message plays well at a Gracie Mansion press conference.
It plays very differently when the mayor's staff is in the next room asking the same agency to let specific people go.
A Federal Judge Already Forced Mamdani to Hand ICE Names from a Bronx Shelter
Federal Judge Lewis Kaplan ruled on November 7, 2026, that Mamdani's administration must comply with an ICE subpoena.
ICE wanted names and birth dates of homeless men living in a Bronx shelter as part of a criminal investigation.
Kaplan found the records "material and relevant to the enforcement of the federal immigration laws."
Mamdani spokesperson Ivonne Rodriguez said the administration was "evaluating next steps."
New York Attorney General Letitia James said her office was reviewing whether to appeal.
Two days later, Trump named Stephen Miller White House Chief of Staff, replacing Wiles.
Mamdani lost a court fight and lost his backchannel in the same week.
The timing could not have landed worse for a mayor whose entire national reputation rests on standing up to federal immigration agents.
One week he was defending sanctuary policy in court.
The next week the man who wrote Trump's deportation playbook got the office next to the Oval.
Stephen Miller Has Never Needed a Reason to Say No to Zohran Mamdani
Miller built the deportation machine Trump himself called too tough on 60 Minutes.
Susie Wiles ran interference for Mamdani's requests because she had the standing in the Oval Office to make a case.
Miller made his name doing the opposite of that.
Politico's sourcing admits it is unlikely Miller will keep playing ball the way Wiles did.
Trump has said he wants the murderers out and then he'll see what happens with everyone else.
That sentence used to leave Mamdani room to negotiate through Wiles.
Now the man reading that sentence back to Trump every morning is the one who wrote the deportation list in the first place.
Awawdeh can call Miller cruel on cable news all he wants.
Mamdani's staff still needs a favor from him, and cruelty was never what stopped Miller from saying no.
Sources:
- Rusty Weiss, "Mamdani's Staff Is Panicking As Their ICE Favor Pipeline Just Hit a Brick Wall Named Stephen Miller," RedState, November 10, 2026.
- Ward Clark, "Win: Federal Judge Orders NYC Mayor Mamdani to Hand Over Data to ICE on Homeless Men," RedState, November 7, 2026.
- Breitbart, "Mamdani: Our Anti-ICE Politics Are Working Across the Nation," Breitbart, November 5, 2026.










